Dryland assessment - questions of data interpretation

  • Asked
  • Active
  • Viewed 2408 times
0

Hi!

We are starting to pin down the preliminary card content for our Collect Earth baseline for tree-based landscape restoration in Ethiopia. I read the Dryland Assessment and have a few questions (I originally sent an email to drylands.report@fao.org but it bounced back):

1- how the number of trees (counted individually) relates to % tree. What is the added value of using both? My understanding is that the number of trees should be counted over the whole 0.5 ha plot while the % tree is only counting how many of the dots touch a tree.

2- in Ethiopia, trees can be as small as 2 m height. I am wondering if counting both trees and shrubs makes sense. If someone wants to share his/her opinion, I am interested.

3- the LULC map is based on which card: land class or IPCC class?

4- when our area crosses dryland and non-dryland, which hierarchical rule to use? Ideally, people would use different hierarchical rules but in practice, it does not seem realistic.

5- Is crown cover density (from the Dryland Assessment) the same as percent tree (in the CE cards)?

6- the crown cover density map is based on percent tree or number of trees?

7- the number of trees by land use class = average number of trees/ha for a specific land use class x area of that land use class?

8- why the threshold for trees not to be counted is 30?

9- Am I right to think that the map of % tree cover relies on a classification undertaken in GEE with Landsat and uses the spectral value of the central plot point as training area?

10- I realize there are some statistical rules in play that makes that if we have enough points in the area, the plots are representative of the whole area but I am not a statistician and it is hard to grasp. I feel that some of the data collected should not be considered as representative of the whole area but I don't know which ones.... If there are some red flags when interpreting the data from a statistical point of view, thanks for highlighting them.

Cheers and thanks for any help!

Florence

Be the first one to answer this question!

Markdown text. Shortcuts: Ctrl+B bold, Ctrl+I italic, Ctrl+K link, Ctrl+E code, Ctrl+Shift+V paste as plain text. Tab indents list items and code; press Escape, then Tab, to leave the text box.

Insert an image

Say what the image shows, for people who can't see it.

Tip: type a few words from the error message, or put a tag in [brackets] to look only there.

Menu

Keyboard shortcuts

Anywhere

?
Show this list
/
Search
g h
Go to the home page
g q
Go to the questions
g t
Go to the tags
g u
Go to the users
a
Ask a question

Lists of questions

j k
Next or previous question
Enter
Open the question

Question pages

j k
Next or previous post

Shortcuts never apply while you type in a text field. Members can turn them off in their preferences.